Before I became an NHS Trust Chair, I spent many years in the world of third sector group facilitation and training. Working with national charities I was supported to develop my own skills through academic and practical learning. As a result, I became a provider of “training the trainer” courses, as well as group and team facilitation in organisations, often being called on to facilitate where teams were dysfunctional or not working as effectively as they wished to.
In my two six-year stints as an NHS Chair, I drew on many of the skills I’d learned in my facilitation career. This blog aims to set out how I sought to apply one particular learning model: John Heron’s inspirational work, The Facilitators’ Handbook (now available online in a revised format at https://johnheron-archive.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/cfh.pdf). I recently re-read this book and saw just how often I brought its frameworks into my approach to being an NHS Chair.
Key to Heron’s work are his six dimensions of facilitator style:
- The planning dimension. This focuses on the goals and aims of the group, and what the facilitator should do to fulfil them. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How shall the group acquire its objectives and its programme?”
- The meaning dimension. This focuses on participants’ understanding of what is going on, how they make sense of their experiences together; their reasons for both doing things and reacting to others in that space. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How shall meaning be given to and found in the experiences and actions of group members?”
- The confronting dimension. This is the challenge aspect of facilitation. It helps raise consciousness about any resistance and avoidance that need to be dealt with. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How shall the group’s consciousness be raised about these matters?”
- The feeling dimension. This focuses on the management of feeling and emotion within the group. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How shall the life of feeling and emotion within the group be handled?”
- The structuring dimension. This focuses on the methods of learning within the group that shape how it can work together effectively. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How can the group’s learning be structured?”
- The valuing dimension. This focuses on creating a supportive climate which honours and celebrates the individual group members, so they can be genuine, empowered, and true to themselves. Heron’s facilitative question is: “How can such a climate of personal value, integrity and respect be created?”
Alongside his dimensions, Heron proposes three modes of facilitation:
- The hierarchical mode. Here the facilitator directs the group’s work, exercising power over it, and acting on behalf of the group. The facilitator alone decides on the objectives and the programme, interprets and gives meaning, challenges resistances, manages group feeling and emotion, and provides structures to enable effectiveness. In this mode, the facilitator is in charge of all major decisions on all dimensions of the group’s processes.
- The co-operative mode. Here the facilitator shares power over the group’s processes and how the dimensions are managed. Critically, their role is to enable the group to become more self-directing by conferring with them and prompting them, including to decide on its programme of work, to give meaning to experiences, and to confront resistances. The facilitator may share their own view which, though influential, is not final but one among many.
- The autonomous mode. Here the facilitator respects the autonomy of the group, ceding power to give the group the freedom to find their own way, without intervention. This does not mean the abdication of responsibility, but rather is focused on creating conditions within which people can exercise self-determination.
Heron’s work explores each dimension and mode in much more detail and is, of course, designed for the group learning environment rather than the Boardroom. But I think his work can bring useful prompts in the Boardroom for a Chair to pro-actively consider and apply.
So how would I do this in practice?
As Chair, first and foremost, I would think about the mode best suited at a given time, for a given circumstance. For example, as a new Chair, or with a Board with new members, the hierarchical mode is important. It enables the building and holding of a shared understanding of how this version of this Board will operate. It is the chance to set out my leadership style and my expectations of others. It can help set key values, like ways of working, and how we prepare for, participate, and challenge in meetings. It lets me articulate my perspective on how the organisation’s values should be exhibited in the Board. My experience suggests being active in this mode initially, and from time to time when the Board’s membership changed, was instrumental in building (and occasionally re-setting) psychological safety for Board members to be their best.
However, I think the bulk of the work of the Chair, if the principles of being a unitary Board are to be upheld, is to seek to operate in the co-operative mode. Fundamentally, this helps place the Chair as a peer in the Board, with a voice that is of equal value to others’. Whilst I would argue this leads to a stronger Board, it does require the Chair to feel okay with stepping back a bit! For example: if, when a paper is presented, the Chair immediately sets out their own view on the course of action or the best outcome, they are acting in the hierarchical mode. Whilst this may sometimes be helpful (e.g. if there are tight deadlines to decisions, or wider politics at play that mean there is really only one option that is acceptable, despite a range of options being considered), there is a real risk this closes down other views and, importantly, closes down a unitary Board approach. I’ve worked with hundreds of Non-Executive and Executive Directors, and there is a strong recognition of “holding back and picking my fights” in a Board discussion if a Chair has set out their view of “the” answer before others have contributed.
In the co-operative mode, I would invite others to contribute, question, and challenge, before giving my own personal view. This increases the chances of diverse thinking being expressed, leading to better, more unitary, decisions. I would still contribute, but as a peer. Holding back on my own views has resulted in them being tested and challenged similarly to others’ views in a way that a Chair initially framing their own perspective is less likely to achieve.
The autonomous mode may seem less applicable in the Boardroom per se, but it can be applicable in how a Chair enables other parts of the governance of a Trust to operate, including Board Committees and (for Foundation Trusts) how Councils of Governors work. For example, it can be a powerful underscoring of the roles of Committees for their ways of working to be set within that group (in the context of appropriate Board scrutiny, of course) rather than to be dictated by the Chair. And chairing a Council of Governors is very different to chairing a Board, in that the Chair is not a direct peer of the Governors. Taking an approach that it is “their” meeting, which the Chair is facilitating sits in the autonomous mode, though can bring different challenges for a Chair, especially if Governors have different perspectives to the Trust Board.
After assessing the mode I seek to operate in, I can then bring the lens of Heron’s dimensions to my chairing. After all, in any meeting where I am there as Chair, any and all of the six dimensions can operate at any time. So, key to being effective as a Chair using this approach, is preparation.
I reckon I have chaired well over 120 Board meetings (including extraordinary ones as well as scheduled ones), and the preparation I put into my later ones was as great as that I put into the early ones. Alongside reading all the papers for a meeting, I would proactively consider if and how the different dimensions might apply; which of them I might seek to bring to the fore; and importantly, whether my level of comfort, ability, or knowledge meant I needed to focus on a particular dimension to ensure I brought my best as a Chair, and get the best from the Board.
An example of how I might consider the dimensions in my preparation would be in considering a Board discussion on financial plans being significantly off-track. The obvious dimension likely to come into play is confronting – bringing challenge to unsuccessful actions, questioning unmet milestones, or being alert to any avoidance of difficult decisions. But as Chair, it would be important for me to consider the other dimensions too. In the planning dimension I might consider where in an agenda the financial discussion was scheduled, to ensure it got full attention with appropriate time rather than just going for its usual place in the agenda. In the meaning dimension I might focus on ensuring there is a shared understanding of the Board’s role in the decisions and actions it can take, or in influencing others’ actions. In the feeling dimension I might be alert to the potential range of emotions there could be in the Board (e.g. anger, frustration, worry) as well as emotions specific people with key roles might have, such as the Director of Finance or chair of the Finance Committee. I might use the structuring dimension to help frame the discussion, to keep a focus on the required outcomes rather than going down a rabbit hole of detail. And I might bring the valuing dimension to consider how a difficult conversation could be had with appropriate challenge whilst holding the values of integrity and respect, and holding psychological safety as strongly as possible for everyone.
As with all other potentially helpful frameworks to support Chairs in being the best they can, the application of Heron’s dimensions and modes of facilitation will not always succeed. But I believe bringing a lens of Heron’s thinking into the role of Board Chair can be a helpful tool for enabling a Chair to bring their best more often. I therefore suggest, as part of their preparation for a Board meeting, a Chair explicitly assess the whole meeting and its individual agenda items through the lens of Heron’s work, asking
- “What mode should I operate in to enable the best from the Board?”
- “Which dimensions can I anticipate being in the room, and how might they show?”
How Because It Matters Ltd can help you reflect on being a Chair
If you want to discuss how I might be able to work with you on aspects of being a Chair – through one-to-one coaching, or through Board development – you can contact me via my website at www.becauseitmattersltd.co.uk
Paul Devlin
Director
April 2026